Updated · StampCue Editorial Team

How to choose custom printed packaging and boxes

Compare box style, fit and board strength, print options, minimum order, materials, production time and support before you order custom printed boxes or branded mailers.

What custom packaging is for

Custom packaging protects the product and carries your brand to the customer’s door. A printed mailer box turns a delivery into a small brand moment. A plain shipping box with a printed label or tape does a similar job at a lower cost. For shops that sell online, the box is often the only physical contact a customer has with the business.

The trade off is between look, protection and order size. Fully printed boxes need larger runs and longer production times. Labels, stickers and printed tape can brand stock boxes in small numbers.

Box style, fit and strength

Start with the style. Mailer boxes with a tuck lid suit apparel, cosmetics and subscription boxes. Regular shipping cartons suit heavier goods. Folding cartons are for retail shelves rather than the post. Rigid gift boxes are for high value items.

Fit matters for both cost and damage. Measure the product with any inner packing, then choose the inside dimensions. A box that is too big needs more void fill and can cost more to ship. Ask about board grade too: a single wall board suits light items, while a double wall board protects heavier or fragile goods.

Print options and artwork

Compare printing on the outside only, the inside only, or both. Full colour print looks rich but costs more than one or two spot colours on kraft board. Check whether the printer gives you a dieline, the flat template of the box, and whether it reviews your file before production. A file check catches artwork that crosses a fold or sits under a flap.

Minimum order and materials

Minimum order is often the deciding factor for a small brand. Some suppliers start at a few dozen boxes, others at a hundred or more. Work out how many boxes you will use before the design changes, and how much space you have to store flat stock. A slightly larger run can be better value per box, but only if the boxes are used before your branding or product sizes change.

Material claims vary. Suppliers may list kraft paper, recycled board, compostable or biodegradable options. Treat these as product descriptions, ask which certificate or test backs each claim, and check that the material suits the weight of your product.

How the suppliers differ

customboxes.io lists kraft paper and biodegradable materials and has a minimum order of 100 units. BoxUp lists compostable materials and starts at a lower minimum of 25 units, which suits smaller test runs.

OnlineLabels takes a different route. Its stated range is custom labels rather than boxes, with no minimum beyond one unit, an online design tool, a file check and two to three days of production. Branded labels on stock boxes are a practical start for a business not ready for a full box run.

JiaroPack is a US supplier that lists shipping boxes, padded envelopes, poly mailers, void fill, retail bags and food packaging, with custom printing available. It offers business accounts and support by email, phone and chat, which helps if you buy packing supplies and printed packaging from one place.

What to check before you order

Ask for a sample or a plain prototype in your chosen size before a printed run. Pack a real product in it, drop test it, and post it to yourself. Check the production time for printed boxes, which can be much longer than for stock items, and plan reorders before you run out. A reorder of the same design is quicker when the supplier keeps your dieline and artwork on file, so ask whether it does.

Read the policy on print faults and wrong sizes, since custom boxes cannot be resold. Confirm the delivery country and whether boxes ship flat on a pallet that needs a loading area.

How to shortlist

Decide between fully printed boxes and branded stock boxes. Then filter suppliers by box style, minimum order, material and delivery country. Compare support channels and production times, and order a prototype before you commit. The custom printed packaging comparison lists more suppliers with their stated facts.

See the full ranking: Top custom printed packaging and boxes compared →

Sources