What you are really buying
Ink and toner are a running cost that lasts as long as the printer. The cartridge price is only part of it. What matters is how many good pages you get from each cartridge, how often it fails, and how quickly you can get a new one when the printer stops.
Inkjet printers use liquid ink and suit low volume colour printing. Laser printers use toner powder and suit higher volumes of text. The choices below apply to both, but toner cartridges last longer and cost more per cartridge, so a faulty one hurts more. A low priced printer with costly cartridges can end up costing more over its life than a dearer printer with cheaper refills.
Original, compatible or remanufactured
Original cartridges come from the printer maker. They work as intended and keep you on the maker’s support terms. Compatible cartridges are new units made by another company to fit your printer. Remanufactured cartridges are used originals that have been cleaned, refilled and checked.
Third party cartridges usually cost less per page, but quality varies between suppliers. Look for a clear promise to replace a cartridge that leaks, streaks or is not recognised by the printer. Some printers check for original chips after a firmware update, so read the supplier’s advice on updates before you install one.
Printer fit and page yield
Search by your exact printer model, not the series name. Cartridges with similar codes can be for different regions or models. If you are unsure, read the code from the cartridge you are replacing.
Page yield is the number of pages a cartridge is rated to print under a standard test. High yield cartridges cost more but print more pages, which often lowers the cost of each page. Compare yields side by side rather than the cartridge price alone. Colour sets and multipacks can lower the cost of each cartridge, but they only pay off if you use all the colours at a similar rate.
Delivery, accounts and recycling
A printer that runs dry before a deadline makes delivery speed matter. Next day delivery helps if you do not keep spares. Otherwise keep one spare of each colour and reorder when you open it.
For an office, a business account can bring invoicing and order history. Ask, too, whether the shop takes back empty cartridges for recycling, since used units should not go into general waste.
How the shops differ
123inkjets is a specialist ink and toner shop founded in 1999 that serves the US and Canada. It offers business accounts and support by email, phone and a help centre. It does not offer next day delivery, so it suits planned reorders more than emergencies.
123tinta is an ink and toner specialist that offers next day delivery, which helps when a cartridge runs out without warning. 4inkjets also focuses on ink and toner, with support through a help centre only, so check the answers you might need there before you order.
inkClub is another store dedicated to ink and toner. Check its delivery countries and support options on its page, since they shape how quickly you can solve a problem cartridge.
What to check before you order
Read the returns policy for faulty cartridges, including how long you have to report a problem and whether you must send the cartridge back. Check whether opened cartridges can be returned if they turn out not to fit. Confirm the delivery country and time. Ask about storage as well, since cartridges carry a use by date and can dry out in heat.
If you switch to third party cartridges, test one set before you buy in bulk. Print a few colour pages and a long text document and compare them with your current results.
How to shortlist
Write down your printer model and the cartridge codes. Decide between original and third party cartridges, then filter shops by delivery country and speed. Compare return terms for faulty cartridges, business account options and support channels. The ink and toner cartridges comparison lists more shops with their stated facts.